A VA decision becomes final once the appeal period closes, but a narrow rule keeps the door open in one situation. That rule lets a veteran ask the agency to reverse a final decision that contained a plain mistake. We explain what the rule requires and where it stops.
Final Decisions Can Be Revised for Error
38 CFR section 3.105 provides that a final VA decision is accepted as correct unless it contains clear and unmistakable error. A veteran can ask for review at any time after the decision becomes final, and the VA can start a review on its own. When the evidence establishes that kind of error, the prior decision will be reversed or amended.
A reversal has the same effect as if the corrected decision had been made on the date of the reversed decision. That change moves the VA effective date back to the original decision, and back pay can follow. It’s what makes the request worth the effort.
The Regulation Defines the Error Narrowly
Clear and unmistakable error is, in the regulation’s words, “a very specific and rare kind of error,” and the standard is demanding. It’s an error of fact or of law that, once pointed out to a later reviewer, compels a finding that the result would have been manifestly different. If it isn’t absolutely clear that a different result would have followed, the error doesn’t qualify. That’s a high bar.
The regulation describes the error in terms of two situations. In the first, the correct facts, as known at the time, weren’t before the VA. In the second, the rules in effect at the time were applied incorrectly. The review is limited to the record and the law as they stood on the decision date, and the VA’s duty to assist doesn’t apply to a request of this kind.
Some Disagreements Don’t Qualify
38 CFR section 20.1403 governs the same kind of challenge to Board of Veterans’ Appeals decisions. It applies the same demanding definition, which requires an error that would have manifestly changed the outcome. It also lists what isn’t clear and unmistakable error:
- A new diagnosis that corrects an earlier diagnosis the Board considered
- A failure to fulfill the duty to assist
- A disagreement about how the facts were weighed or evaluated
Those exclusions explain why this request isn’t a second appeal. A veteran who thinks an examiner’s opinion deserved more weight is disagreeing about how evidence was evaluated. A claim that the VA never gathered certain records falls under the duty to assist exclusion, though missing records can still matter on appeal. A later change in how a regulation is interpreted also doesn’t turn an earlier, correct decision into an error.
A Request Must Name the Error Specifically
The request has to be in writing and signed. It must set out the specific error alleged and explain why the result would have been manifestly different without it. Broad statements that the VA failed to follow its rules or didn’t provide due process aren’t enough. Our Miami service-connected disability lawyer team drafts that statement from the decision itself.
Preparing that kind of request means reading the rating decision, the evidence list, and the regulations in force on the decision date side by side. Veterans can ask a Miami veterans disability lawyer to identify the page of the file or the rule that supports each allegation. A vague claim of unfairness gives a reviewer nothing to test.
Appeals and Error Reviews Run on Separate Tracks
An issue the Board or a court already decided on appeal can’t be revised under section 3.105(a). A decision still inside its appeal period belongs on the appeal path. Appealing a VA decision within the deadline is a different task than proving an old error.
New evidence is the other dividing line. A request for revision can’t add it, but a supplemental claim can. The VA’s duty to assist applies on that route, which isn’t true of the request described here.
Reviewing an Old Decision
Julie L. Glover is a founding partner of our firm and a VA-accredited attorney who represents veterans in all phases of the VA disability process. Glover Luck LLP represents veterans nationwide, and our attorneys read the decision, the rating sheet, and the evidence list side by side. That comparison separates a specific error from a disagreement.
A final decision can be reopened, but the standard for doing so is strict. Miami veterans who believe a decision was wrong can reach out to us, and we’ll compare it with the record as it stood on the decision date. Our attorneys also confirm which decision is the final one before anything is filed.